Posted by: baliwhat | April 12, 2009

Freaking out over priority subway seats

When I started reading a NY Times blog post about this blog, People Who Sit In The Disability Seats When I’m Standing On My Crutches, I first thought, I like this guy’s style- it’s like if I were to publicly call out all the assholes who park illegally in handicapped parking spots.  But as I read further, and then actually read the blog, I realized this guy is just an angry jerk who needs to chill out and be glad he’s only temporarily disabled.

Matt Muro was angered when people didn’t give up the priority seats on the subway- labeled “priority seating for persons with disabilities”- when they saw him standing there on crutches he uses due to a stress fracture.  So he started taking pictures of these folks and posting them on his blog with vitriolic titles like “Hi, I’m an Asshole”.

I have so many problems with this I don’t know where to start.  So I’ll start by suggesting you check out the aforementioned “asshole’s” picture here.  He appears to be able-bodied, sure, but there is an open priority seat on each side of him.  So what’s the problem?  What is Mr. Muro complaining about?  The priority seats aren’t like disabled parking spaces- they’re not supposed to be off-limits to able-bodied people at all times- they’re to be vacated if someone needs them.  Two are vacant in the “asshole” picture.  I see no problem here, and no reason to call the poor guy an asshole.

I could go on like this forever.  But I won’t, so here are most of the rest of the reasons I think this guy is full of it:

  • Many people have physical disabilities that are not visible.  There are myriad valid medical reasons why someone might need that priority seat that Mr. Muro (or anyone else) can’t see.
  • A lot of the people pictured are SLEEPING.  What does he expect them to do, spot his crutches through their see-through eyelids?
  • Dude, you gotta advocate for yourself.  If you need the seat, ASK.  Maybe you think the world should revolve around people with disabilities, that the seas should part for us (personally, I don’t; I just want to be treated like the normal person that I am)- but that’s not the case.  Speak up if you want to sit down.

Et cetera.  Basically, give me a break.  And every time Mr. Muro sees someone taking up one of his precious priority seats, he should comfort his poor hurt self with the knowledge that he is only experiencing a tiny fraction of a percent of the adversity that people like me experience all their lives.  Hell, if I could even get into half the subway stations I wanted to, it would make my life a lot easier.  Maybe he should focus his photoblogging efforts on the lack of stations’ accessibility, and put his anger to good use.


Responses

  1. I noticed that too about the “ass-hole,” there are seats beside him and if whiny crutches dude made a move to sit down then already-sitting-guy would probably shift over a bit to give him more room. Just assuming people are un-charitable is just ass-holish.

  2. Exactly. The blogger guy assumes everyone is maliciously seat-hogging to spite him, or because they’re just that uncaring…yes, there are a lot of selfish jerks out there, but there are more generally good folks, in my experience.

  3. There are jerks everywhere. Just today, some redhead was holding a child and claiming people were pushing into her with their bags in a crowded subway train. Where are people suppose to go in a very crowded subway car? This woman then went on to claim that because she was holding a child, she had right of way to hug the pole by doorway and that anyone else could go to the “space” beside her. In truth, there was NO space at all – the place was crowded – and to get to that space you’d have to go through her – meaning shoving past her. To add insult, she then puts her child down who can stand and walk. Um, yeah, you really needed this spot because you were holding a child.

    I felt bad for the people near her, they didn’t deserve her abuse, they were just trying to get to work and couldn’t move much since the train was so full of people. -_-


Leave a response

Your response:

Categories